New drug shows promise for preventing migraines
"Millions of people are set to benefit from the first new migraine drug in 20 years," reports the Mail Online.
New research found the injectable drug erenumab cut the number of days people had migraines from an average of 8 a month to between 4 and 5 a month.
Millions of people in the UK get migraines. Symptoms include severe headache, dizziness, nausea, and aversion to light.
Migraine-specific drugs include a group of drugs called triptans, which are used to try to ease the symptoms of attack once it starts, and several drugs that are used to try to prevent attacks.
But these drugs aren't always effective and can have unwelcome side effects.
The new drug is thought to disable a protein known as calcitonin gene-related peptide. Previous research found this protein may play a part in migraine symptoms.
A second drug that works in a similar way, fremanezumab, is also being tested.
Any new drugs will have to be licensed by the European Medicines Agency and assessed by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) before they can be made available on the NHS.
Find more information on the treatments currently available for migraines, as well as advice on avoiding potential migraine triggers.
Where did the story come from?
The research on erenumab was carried out by researchers from King's College Hospital in the UK, the Universitätsmedizin Berlin in Germany, St Göran Hospital in Sweden, the Medical University of Innsbruck in Austria, Mercy Research, and the pharmaceutical company Amgen in the US.
It was published in the peer-reviewed New England Journal of Medicine. The study was funded by Amgen and Novartis, pharmaceutical companies co-developing the drug.
The UK media greeted the study with enthusiasm, with the Mail Online hailing it as a "Holy Grail" treatment, while The Daily Telegraph said it could "slash in half" the number of days people suffered migraines.
Oddly, The Guardian and The Times said it reduced how long migraines lasted by half, which seems to be a misreading of the study results. The study didn't publish data about the length of migraine attacks.
The media reports focused on erenumab, with only BBC News discussing the study on fremanezumab (possibly because it's used to treat the less common type, chronic migraine), so we do the same here.
What kind of research was this?
This was a double-blind randomised controlled trial, the best type of study to show whether a treatment works.
But the study was quite selective about the participants included, so we don't know whether the drug will work for all people with migraine.
This study was multi-centre, conducted across 121 sites across the US, which reduces the risk of the treating team influencing the results.
What did the research involve?
Researchers recruited 955 adults aged 18 to 65 who regularly had at least 4 days of migraine a month on average.
First participants were asked to record their migraine symptoms for 4 weeks using an electronic diary.
The researchers then randomly assigned 317 to a monthly injection of 70mg erenumab, 319 to a monthly injection of 140mg erenumab, and 319 people to a monthly placebo injection.
People continued to record their migraine symptoms and any other symptoms for 24 weeks (about 6 months) while having the monthly injections.
Researchers looked at results from the last 2 months of the trial to see if different treatments had different results.
The trial then continued with everyone being treated with one or other dose of erenumab, but this phase hasn't been analysed yet.
The researchers excluded anyone from taking part in the trial who hadn't responded to more than 2 types of existing migraine-preventative drugs.
People could take other migraine-preventative or migraine treatment drugs during the study.
The main outcome measured was change in the average number of days of migraine a month in the final 2 months, compared with the 4-week baseline period.
Researchers also recorded the proportion of people who saw the number of days on which they had migraines fall by half (which is considered a clinically significant result), and changes to people's scores on questionnaires about how migraines affected their lives.
What were the basic results?
During the first 4 weeks (without treatment), people had on average 8.3 days of migraine a month.
In the last 2 months of the trial, on average:
- people taking erenumab 70mg had migraines on 3.2 fewer days
- people taking erenumab 140mg had migraines on 3.7 fewer days
- people taking a placebo had migraines on 1.8 fewer days
People taking erenumab were also more likely to see the number of days they had migraines fall by half:
- 44.3% of people taking 70mg erenumab 70mg
- 50% of people taking 140mg erenumab 140mg
- 26.6% of people taking placebo
Compared with placebo, people taking erenumab 70mg were 2.13 times as likely to have their migraine days fall by half (odds ratio(OR) 2.13, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.52 to 2.98) and those taking erenumab 140mg were 2.81 times as likely (OR 2.81, 95% CI 2.01 to 3.94).
The number of possible side effects reported was similar between those taking placebo and those taking erenumab, suggesting they may not be specific to the drug.
Symptoms reported included soreness from the injection, colds and tiredness. And there are reports of people responding negatively to receiving regular injections even though they were only injected with water.
How did the researchers interpret the results?
The researchers say their results "suggest that erenumab may be useful for the prevention of episodic migraine", but "further trials are needed to determine the long-term safety of erenumab and the durability of its effects".
This is a good-quality study that holds promise for a treatment that may help people who have migraines.
But there are limitations to be aware of:
- The study didn't include people who had found no effect from more than 2 classes of migraine prevention drugs, so we don't know whether it works in these people.
- The study didn't include people with chronic migraine (migraines on 15 or more days a month).
- The trial period of 6 months may not be long enough to pick up all possible side effects. The trial continued beyond this to allow for a safety analysis, so more information about the drug's safety may emerge.
Only half the people who took erenumab saw results as good as those stated in the newspaper headlines. Some people may not have seen any improvement: we don't know if it works for everyone.
The drug has to be approved and then assessed by NICE, who will decide whether it should be prescribed on the NHS.
Analysis by Bazian
Edited by NHS Choices
Links to the headlines
Hope at last for migraine sufferers: 'Holy grail' monthly jab which halves attacks could be approved by NHS in new year
Mail Online, November 29 2017
Migraine drug could halve the length of attacks, study shows
The Guardian, November 30 2017
Migraine therapy that cut attacks hailed as 'huge deal'
BBC News, November 30 2017
First migraine drug in 20 years can half number of attacks, study shows
The Daily Telegraph, November 30 2017
Breakthrough migraine drug Erenumab halves the length of attacks, research claims
The Independent, November 30 2017
Links to the science
Goadsby PJ, Reuter U, Hallström Y, et al. A Controlled Trial of Erenumab for Episodic MigraineThe New England Journal of Medicine. Published online November 30 2017